Monday, August 15, 2011

Common Law Marriages

Thanks to another great suggestion from a "Wise Latina" from the Wise Latinas Linked network I am a part of, I have another blog topic: Common Law Marriages.  I wanted to expand the topic to talk about same sex marriages and civil unions but I will save that for a future blawg post.

I also invite you to visit the Wise Latinas Linked blog run by Rebecca Aguilar.  The blog is a great source of information that affects Latinas.

Wise Latinas Linked

Common Law Marriages

So what is a common law marriage?  I'm sure you've heard that if you live with a partner long enough (usually 7 years) and you "act" married that "ta-da"! you are in a common law marriage.
Well, not really.

According to Black's Law Dictionary:
To be defined as a common-law marriage within the states that allow it, the two people must: agree that they are married, live together, and present themselves as husband and wife. Common-law marriage is generally a non-ceremonial relationship that requires "a positive mutual agreement, permanent and exclusive of all others, to enter into a marriage relationship, cohabitation sufficient to warrant a fulfillment of necessary relationship of man and wife, and an assumption of marital duties and obligations." Black's Law Dictionary 277 (6th ed. 1990).
But in fact, did you know that out of the 50 U.S. states only nine states actually recognize common law marriages? There are also rules that you have to follow to be deemed married under the common law in these states:

1. Alabama
2. Colorado
3. Kansas
4. Rhode Island
5. South Carolina
6. Iowa
7. Montana
8. Oklahoma
9. Texas
(oh and the District of Columbia)

Don't see your state listed above?  A few states have "grandfather clauses" where basically if you had a common law marriage established before a certain date they recognize your marriage (Georgia, Idaho, Ohio, Oklahoma, and Pennsylvania).

Two other states allow a "common law marriage" in special circumstances.
New Hampshire: for probate purposes only
Utah: only if validated by a court order.

There are also rules that must apply for one of the nine states above to recognize your "common law marriage".  You can research each state's rule if you want, but generally you have to live together, and act like you're married (known as "holding out"), like filing joint tax returns, assuming a spouse's last name, etc.
The U.S. Constitution is supposed to require each state to respect the laws of their sister states but many states have challenged common law marriages that are not recognized in their state.  In other words, if you do have a valid common law marriage in your state, it is probably not a good idea to move to another state that doesn't recognize common law marriages. 

Oh, and once in you're in a common law marriage the only way out is a real divorce done in officially in court.

For more information:
If you want more information about common law marriages or you want to know what your particular state's laws are, I highly recommend the following website: The National Conference of State Legislatures


You've probably never heard of this organization but it's a great online resource.  It's a bi-partisan organization that provides information for policymakers and legislators.  They have an "issues and research" section that is further subdvided into sub-topics such as "human services", "education" and "health". The site provides a breakdown of each state's position on popular topics and you can read about proposed bills.

Saturday, August 13, 2011

Pro Se Divorce

Someone recently suggested a topic- How to get a divorce when you don't have the money for a lawyer?
Well, first of all, I'm not a family attorney.  Well great, you may wonder, why are you writing a blawg about family and law then?  Because I'm a mother and attorney and love to read about any topics that have to do with family rights, women's rights, children's rights, etc.  I also think it's important to talk about current events and laws and how they affect certain groups of people.
That said, seriously, what does someone do when they need to file for for divorce but can't afford an attorney?  The first most obvious answer is to seek some kind of free or reduced price legal aid.  I reside in Illinois and there are some great online resources such as www.illinoislegalaid.org.  That is one of my favorite sites because it's easy to use and actually walks you through the steps of the legal process for a variety of topics.  They also have actual forms you can use to file in court.

If you live in another state I'm sure there are great resources in your state and I would be happy to research some if needed.
If you feel you truly cannot afford an attorney then you should qualify for some kind of aid from a legal aid organization in your area.  Some in the Chicagoland area that come to mind are the Cabrini Green Legal Aid Foundation, The Chicago Legal Clinic and The Legal Assistance Foundation of Metropolitan Chicago. Those are just the ones that popped into my head.  There are many more.  In fact, if you live in the Chicagoland area here is an excellent resource I found that was compiled by the Chicago Bar Association and Illinoislegalaid.org.  It's an awesome booklet that gives you a list of legal aid foundations, as well as a great list of other resources you can use such as the help desk phone numbers for all the courthouses.  The booklet is easy to use and I highly recommend taking a look at it if you need a place to start.

The Illinois State Bar Association also has a great website that has a whole section dedicated to "Divorce".  It includes videos and FAQ
.  

My fear as an attorney in advising people to defend themselves against a lawsuit or participate in a divorce as a pro-se litigant is that the individual will not benefit from the laws in their state without having a good attorney on their side.  We have all seen the movies that depict pro-se defendants or litigants in a courtroom doing a much better job at representing themselves than an attorney ever would.  I immediately think of My Cousin Vinny where Vinny in the end, did a pretty good at defending his nephew, (though I suppose Vinny was sort-of a lawyer, but not quite).


In reality however, a pro-se litigant is going to be faced with many hurdles from the moment he/she steps into a courtroom.  Most likely the pro-se party won't be versed in standard courtroom demeanor- how to address the judge and opposing counsel when up at the podium.  They probably won't know how to "check in" when they arrive in court.  They may not know how to find their case on the call that day.  Aside from basic courtroom demeanor, many times pro-se litigants will not have access to routine motions and petitions that attorneys have at their disposal.  It may take a pro-se litigant four hours to draft a simple divorce petition, that would take an attorney 30 minutes to prepare.  They are usually not well versed in the law and often times may request relief in court that just cannot be sought.  I could go on and on but the bottom line is that if you're going to defend yourself or litigate a matter in court without an attorney there are some basic things you should know.
THINGS TO KNOW
1. Use the pro-se help desks
- Go to the local courthouse and ask questions.  Ask for help.  Many times there are help desks where actual attorneys volunteer their time and can guide you in the right direction on how to begin the process including giving you actual forms you must file.

2. Know the notice requirements in your jurisdiction
- you basically have to mail any motions or petitions you file to opposing counsel and anyone else involved in a matter within a certain time before the matter is heard in court, or your motion will be denied.  Many times you must include an affidavit or a certificate of service that you sign and date swearing that you mailed the documents in the mail to opposing parties.  There is also such a thing as serving someone by publication.  This means that if you cannot locate a party you can sometimes publish a notice in a local newspaper for a certain amount of time.

3. Dress Nice
-sounds basic, but many times pro-se litigants do not dress the part and show up in court dressed overly casual.  You should take the court seriously and show respect for the court by looking nice.  You don't necessarily have to be in a suit, but do not wear jeans or a hat to court!

4. Don't talk to opposing counsel directly when up at the podium.  Talk to the judge.
-when it comes time to address the court make sure you do not have a conversation with opposing parties while up at the podium.  You must do that before or after the matter is heard.  You should only be talking to the judge when you step up to the podium.  Also make sure to address the judge as "judge" or "your honor" and that's it!  Not Mr, or Mrs., or Sir.  Also don't ever ever interrupt the judge!


5. Show up to court on time.
- in fact show up early and find out if you have to "check-in" before court with the deputy or clerk.  They will appreciate it and they may call your case earlier if they know all parties are present.  This can save you a lot of time.

6. Know the law and the rules of procedure in your jurisdiction.
-Did you make sure to file the correct documents? After you present your petition or motion you will most likely have the judge rule on your motion and enter some kind of "order" either agreeing with you disagreeing with you.  But what if opposing counsel wants to oppose your motion or petition and drafts a legal response to your motion.  Are you ready to do legal research if needed?  You will only be given a few weeks to file a response and you will have to access to a law library or database such as lexis-nexis or westlaw.

There are some rules of procedure that are very specific to the court house you may be in.  Such as requiring all motions to be typed in size 12 font in Times New Roman font.  Or a goofy rule might be in place that requires motions to be no longer than 5 pages.  Other times, even a particular judge may have a specific rule that only applies in their courtroom!  Yes, when you are in a judge's courtroom you are in their little universe and must follow their rules!  I have known judges that require all motions to be hand delivered to their chambers at least 7 days before the matter is heard in court.  You can often times find these rules on the court's website.  Or ask for help!

7.  Standards
-Don't forget, the judge will hold you to the same standard as the lawyer against you who went to law school for 3-4 years and has probably stood in a court room hundreds if not thousands of times.  They will know the law (most of the time), and will know how to handle themselves in court.  You just have to try to do your best and ask for more time to file documents if needed.

8.  Children
-Will children be involved in the divorce proceeding? This can complicate matters since many times children will be appointed their own legal representative in court known in Illinois as  "Guardiam At Litem" or GAL.  Usually you or your spouse will also have to pay for their legal fees!

Determining a proper visitation schedule can also be difficult in that you will also have to make decisions about religious education in the future for your children, how holidays will be handled, who will provide health and life insurance for the child, and college education.

9.  Marital property division and alimony/maintenance
-Have you and your spouse decided who is going to keep what property?  How will you split pensions? 401ks? the house? the cars?  How about alimony? Will anyone be entitled to receive alimony? These particular issues are tricky to give any advice on because different states have different laws about how property is distributed during a divorce and how the right to receive alimony is determined.  There are two legal theories on how property is distributed: Community Property Distribution and Equitable Distribution.  Most states use Equitable Distribution but there are nine states that use Community Property Distribution laws.  Those states are:
-Arizona
-California
-Idaho
-Louisiana
-Nevada
-New Mexico
-Texas
-Washington
-Wisconsin.

Long story short, there are major difference in how property is distributed in a divorce.  Some states also take into account "fault" during a separation and time separated.  I cannot emphasize how important it is to know the laws in your particular state!

10. Are you getting in over your head?
-Finally, if you are going to proceed pro-se in a divorce proceeding, I have found that you have a better chance of success when the divorce is a simple proceeding, and where you and your soon to be ex-spouse can agree on some basic terms of the divorce, such as child custody and property distribution.  There are actual some rules that determine whether a divorce will be a simple divorce or not.  Such as: the time you were married, whether there were children, amount of property, etc.

There are also uncontested divorces that are usually easier to file where everyone agrees on everything.

If you and your spouse cannot agree on anything AND your spouse has paid thousands of dollars for a big name attorney to represent them, it will probably not end well for you.  Try and hire an attorney.  Attorneys often times require a retainer to being work but may allow a payment plan for remaining fees.
If after reading all of this, you still want to be a pro-se litigant please get some kind of free help before stepping into a courtroom.  And remember, you cannot ask the judge for help in your case they will not (and should not) give you legal advice.  Don't walk up to the clerk or court room deputy while court is in session to ask a question- they do not like it.

Unfortunately, if you choose (or feel you have no choice) but to represent yourself pro-se, remember that you are already at a disadvantage in that you do not know the legal system.  You've basically come to a fancy cocktail party wearing your holey jeans and metallica t-shirt.  You will not fit in, and you will have to compensate for that by understanding at least basic courtroom demeanor, procedural rules, and laws.

If you do reside in Illinois, I will defer once again to www.Illionoislegalaid.org.  They have prepared a guide called exactly: "Getting a Divorce in Illinois" that actually gives steps on how to file for divorce.  Some of the steps they can guide you through are:
- preparing forms
- filing your forms
- serving your spouse with divorce papers
- getting a hearing date
- getting ready for your hearing date
- mailing judgment to your spouse
- getting your transcript from the court reporter.
Click here for a link to this guide

Getting a divorce is often times a difficult and emotionally draining process.  The goal should be to come to an amicable agreement between both parties and move on with your life!

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Fetal Sex prediction at 7 weeks

So, The New York Times came out with an article today that discusses a new finding in a study from The Journal of the American Medical Association about fetal sex prediction at 7 weeks.

The objective of the study was:
To document overall test performance of noninvasive fetal sex determination using cell-free fetal DNA and to identify variables that affect performance.
I thought this was interesting because I will admit walking past those sex prediction kits at the pharmacy thinking... should I? Of course those home kits analyze your urine not blood and the results are not accurate.  But according to this study the blood tests (if administered properly) had a pretty high level of accuracy, especially when testing after 20 weeks.

The test as you might have guessed, aims to detect the male "Y" chromosome in the mother's blood.

And... let's go back to basic biology for a minute and remember that, the sex of a baby is determined by the two sex chromosomes inherited from the parents. Normally, a baby will inherit one sex chromosome from the father and one from the mother. Women have two X chromosomes, so she can give either of her X chromosomes. Men have an X and Y so a father can give either his X or Y chromosome.

There's a pretty picture I found on a grammar school website.

Ok now that we're caught up, back to the study.  It basically states that with a blood test it is possible to determine gender as early as 7 weeks gestation at about a 95% success rate.  For most of us this may offer a nice way of finding out the sex of our child very early on before the traditional 20 week "sex" ultrasound.  But the bigger concern is that there will be those who use the test as a sex selection tool, ultimately aborting the unwanted fetuses.

Aside from the moral problems with this early testing, there also come the potential lawsuits against manufacturers of these products for the wrong results.  Such as the lawsuit against Acu-Gen in 2006 where claimants sued Acu-Gen when they were not provided with a refund upon finding out the results were incorrect.  A settlement was reached, and then Acu-gen filed for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy.

Blumer, et al. v. Acu-Gen Biolab, Inc., et al., No. 06-CA-10359-RCL (D. Mass. Mar. 28, 2006)


That's as far as I followed the case, but this type of lawsuit reminds me of the intriguing albeit controversial "wrongful birth/life" lawsuits discussed in one my law school seminars.  Yes, these are malpractice cases where parents have sued medical providers and hospitals claiming that had they known their child was going to be as severely disabled as they are, they would have aborted the child.  Essentially the parents in these cases are alleging that the child would have been "better off dead".  Pretty harsh right? Well, consider the types of severe disabilities that some of these children that were the subject of these lawsuits have had:

-one child had severe retardation, was unable to walk, can only say a few words, is legally blind and has to often be hospitalized.

-another child born with a hole in his diaphragm that resulted in his stomach being located in his chest cavity resulting in liver and kidney failure

-but then another, with spina bifida, paralyzed from the waist down, but mentally normal

The first two cases settled for over a $1 mil each. 

link to CBS new article with more details about wrongful birth cases

While these wrongful birth lawsuits are rare, the legal argument is that the medical negligence caused by the doctor or hospital prevents the parents from making a truly informed decision about whether or not to have the child.